People say

“After the Kalinga war, Ashoka gave up force and disbanded his army.”

Misleading
The fact

Ashoka’s own Rock Edict XIII records his remorse for Kalinga and his turn to dhamma, but the same edict warns the forest peoples that he still has the power to punish, and he kept Kalinga and his army.

The proof

  1. Rock Edict XIII: 1,50,000 people were carried away from Kalinga, 1,00,000 were killed there, and many times that number died.
  2. At Dhauli and Jaugada, in Kalinga itself, Rock Edict XIII is left out and two Separate Edicts addressed to the officials there stand in its place.

01Remorse, and a warning

Edict XIII is the most personal line any Indian emperor carved: the Beloved of the Gods feels sorrow for the killing in Kalinga. In the same breath he tells the atavikas, the forest tribes, that he can be stern, so that they should mend their ways and not be killed. He did not return Kalinga. In Kalinga itself he chose not to inscribe the confession and instead told his officers to rule justly. Ashoka was a remorseful emperor, and still an emperor; the slogan of a disbanded army has no basis.

Read on